The railway police have said that the initial fault in a scuffle aboard the Jan Nayak Express lay with a woman passenger who refused to vacate a seat for another woman travelling with a child, while acknowledging that the GRP personnel involved should have handled the situation better. A viral video shows a Government Railway Police (GRP) official repeatedly striking a woman passenger in the face in the general compartment while other women try to stop him; the woman was seen bleeding from the head.

According to the Senior Divisional Security Commissioner of the Railway Protection Force, the GRP escort was trying to do his job and the fault lay with the female passenger. He added, however, that the official could have handled the matter more calmly and professionally, or waited until the next station for GRP women personnel to board, rather than getting into a physical altercation following her provocation.

Moradabad SP GRP Ashutosh Shukla said the November 18 incident took place after the train, travelling from Bihar to Punjab, departed from Moradabad railway station, where two escort personnel had boarded as part of their duty. Near Matlabpur, a dispute broke out between two groups over a berth. A woman occupying a berth, accompanied by three young women and two men, was asked by a man and a woman holding a child to make space for the woman with the child, but she refused. The escort personnel intervened and asked her to accommodate the other woman.

According to the police, the three women then allegedly turned aggressive and assaulted the personnel on duty, tearing their uniforms, while the two men accompanying them allegedly joined in, snatched the officers' mobile phones and held them captive. GRP and RPF personnel intervened when the train reached Najibabad. A case has been registered against six people in connection with the incident, and two accused have been arrested and sent to jail, Shukla said.