The Supreme Court has ruled that an unwed mother has a better prima facie claim to custody of her minor child, holding that the absence of marriage or any particular statute cannot negate her preferential custodial rights. A bench of justices N Kotiswar Singh and NV Anjaria made the observation while directing a lawyer father to hand over interim custody of his four-year-old son to the child's German mother, who is based in Singapore.

The court held that the child's welfare would be better served by allowing the mother to take him to Singapore, where she had made concrete arrangements for his schooling and could devote more personal time to his upbringing. Though both parents were found equally capable of caring for the child, the bench said the mother's parenting proposal was "realistic and more beneficial to the child", noting her proactive commitment to his education and flexibility to adjust her professional schedule. The father, who runs a busy law firm with around 53 associates and practises across several cities, was likely to depend substantially on relatives and nannies for the child's everyday needs, the court observed.

The bench expressed doubt that a busy lawyer could spare adequate time for a four-year-old requiring constant personal attention. It said the father would be delegating a significant portion of parental responsibilities to others, a prospect it found not in the best interests of a child already struggling due to a lack of stability. The mother, a vice-president of a video platform, had submitted her employer's work-from-home policy and endorsement, showing she could adjust her hours to be present when the child was not in school.

A NIMHANS report, which examined both parents and the child, found the boy had been away from formal schooling for about four months and strongly recommended he resume classes at the earliest. The court rejected the father's argument that shifting the child to Singapore would uproot him, noting the four-year-old had moved between Delhi, Goa, Kolkata and Germany in his early years and was still at an adaptable stage. It stressed that a child's welfare must prevail over the rights of either parent, irrespective of the statutory framework governing custody.