Companies that provide guarantees for loans taken by their subsidiaries cannot avoid goods and services tax (GST) merely because the guarantee is offered free of charge, the Delhi High Court ruled on Tuesday. A bench of Justices Anil Khetarpal and Bharat Parashar held that a parent company guaranteeing a subsidiary's loan is supplying a service under GST law, since it assumes responsibility if the subsidiary defaults and lets the subsidiary draw on its financial strength and creditworthiness.

The court, however, ruled that the government's rule valuing such guarantees at 1% of the guaranteed amount does not set a compulsory minimum. Companies can establish with evidence that the actual value is lower, and GST must then be calculated on that lower value. It also clarified that GST applies when a guarantee is issued, not every year it remains in force; a guarantee that is renewed, extended or enhanced in value is a new service and attracts GST again, while invocation by a bank after a default does not create fresh liability.

The ruling distinguishes between guarantees issued before 1 July 2017, those issued between 1 July 2017 and 25 October 2023, and those executed, renewed, extended or enhanced from 26 October 2023, when the 1% valuation rule applies. The court set aside tax notices, orders and demands challenged by companies including Sterlite Power Transmission, ReNew, GAIL India, Avaada Energy, Hero Future Energies and Hero Solar Energy to the extent they conflicted with its findings, allowing tax authorities to reassess after giving companies a hearing.

The decision follows a similar judgment by the Gujarat High Court in August, which upheld GST on corporate guarantees but held that the 1% valuation rule could not apply to guarantees issued before 26 October 2023. Tax experts said companies will need to review their guarantee arrangements, maintain records of issuance, renewal and extension, and check input tax credit eligibility rather than mechanically applying the 1% rate.